corresp
July 21, 2006
Mr. Jim B. Rosenberg
Senior Assistant Chief Accountant
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, NE
Washington, D.C. 20549
|
|
|
Re:
|
|
GTx, Inc. |
|
|
Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2005 |
|
|
File No. 000-50549 |
Dear Mr. Rosenberg:
We received your letter dated June 27, 2006, attached as Exhibit A for your reference. Please
find below GTx, Inc.s responses to your comments.
Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2005
Managements Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Critical Accounting Policies, page 48
|
1. |
|
We acknowledge your revenue recognition policy as noted herein and within your Summary
of Significant Accounting Policies in the accompanying notes to your consolidated financial
statements. We believe that your disclosure related to your rebate and sales returns
accruals could be defined and improved. Please provide us with the information that follows
in a disclosure-type format. |
COMMENT:
a) Tell us how you estimate sales returns and recognize revenue according to the provisions of
SFAS No. 48, given your absence of historical experience, which would seem to preclude your ability
to estimate future returns under paragraphs 6/8 of SFAS No. 48. Please also clarify, in a
disclosure-type format, your accounting policy for rebates in relation to EITF No. 01-9,
particularly paragraph 9.
Page Two
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
RESPONSE:
a) On January 1, 2005, GTx, Inc., GTx or the Company, obtained the rights to market and
distribute FARESTON from Shire Corporation. FARESTON was first sold in the United States in
1997 by Schering Plough who sold the distribution rights to Roberts Pharmaceuticals in 1999.
Roberts was later merged into Shire Corporation. Shire distributed FARESTON for
approximately six years. GTx performed due diligence procedures at Shire Corporation prior to
obtaining the rights to distribute FARESTON. The due diligence procedures included obtaining
an understanding of Shires marketing, distribution, and pricing practices, including rebates
and discounts. The majority of the distribution of FARESTON, while Shire distributed the
product as well as currently as GTx distributes the product, is conducted by three large
wholesale distributors. These three distributors accounted for 94% of gross FARESTON sales for
GTx in 2005. GTx entered into distribution agreements with the three largest Shire FARESTON
distributors and several others. GTx continued the same distribution network and marketing
activities.
During its due diligence procedures, the Company examined FARESTON product sales and
product returns data for a twenty-one month period though September 2004. This information
illustrated that product returns over the twenty-one month period represented approximately
nine percent of product sales for the same period. As the Company uses the same wholesale
distributors, the same distribution channels and the same marketing activities as did Shire,
the Company believes that the trend of FARESTON product returns experienced by Shire will be
consistent with FARESTON product returns that it expects in the future. Based on the number
of years Shire distributed FARESTON, the Company believes this historical information provides
it with the ability to make a reasonable estimate of the amount of future returns as required
by paragraph 8 of SFAS No. 48. In addition to utilizing the nine percent historical FARESTON
product return percentage to estimate its product return accrual, the Company continues to
assess actual FARESTON product returns received each period in order to update its estimate of
future product returns as necessary. In addition, the Company utilizes inventory and customer
sales information obtained from its three largest distributors in order to estimate the number
of months of FARESTON inventory on hand which it uses in making its estimate of future product
returns.
The Company sells FARESTON and gives its customers the right to return the product in
accordance with its product return policy. The Company recognizes revenue from the sale of
FARESTON in accordance with paragraph six and eight of SFAS No. 48 at the time of sale only if
all of the following conditions are met:
Page Three
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
a. The sellers price to the buyer is substantially fixed or determinable at the date
of sale. (The sales price of FARESTON is fixed and is communicated to all customers by
way of a published price list for 30 count and 100 count bottles).
b. The buyer has paid the seller, or the buyer is obligated to pay the seller and the
obligation is not contingent on resale of the product. (No sales of FARESTON are
contingent upon the customers ultimate sale of the product).
c. The buyers obligation to the seller would not be changed in the event of theft or
physical destruction or damage of the product. (Theft or physical loss of FARESTON
does not relieve the customer of its obligation to GTx for the sales price).
d. The buyer acquiring the product for resale has economic substance apart from that
provided by the seller. (The Companys three largest wholesale distributors which
account for 94% of FARESTON product sales have substantial economic substance which is
not materially impacted by revenues derived from the sale of FARESTON).
e. The seller does not have significant obligations for future performance to directly
bring about resale of the product by the buyer. (GTx has no future performance
obligation directly to bring about the resale of FARESTON).
f. The amount of future returns can be reasonably estimated depending on many factors
and circumstances that will vary from one case to the next, but including, the
following factors which may impair the ability to make a reasonable estimate:
1. The susceptibility of the product to significant external factors, such as
technological obsolescence or changes in demand. (FARESTON is not immediately
susceptible to obsolescence or significant unforeseen changes in demand due to its
low market share).
2. Relatively long periods in which a particular product may be returned. (Under
GTxs current returned goods policy, which is consistent with industry standards,
FARESTON can be returned to the Company within six months of the expiration of the
product and ninety days after the expiration of the product).
Page Four
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
3. Absence of historical experience with similar types of sales of similar
products, or inability to apply such experience because of changing circumstances,
for example, changes in the selling enterprises marketing policies or
relationships with its customers. (As GTx has retained the same customers,
distribution channel and marketing activities as Shire, it believes that the
historical product return data gives it a reasonable basis for estimating future
product returns).
4. Absence of a large volume of relatively homogeneous transactions. (FARESTON
product sales represent a large volume of homogeneous transactions).
According to EITF No. 01-9, paragraph 9, sales incentives given to customers should be
characterized as a reduction of revenue.
The Company accounts for rebates to certain governmental agencies as a reduction of
revenue.
In future filings beginning with its Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2006, the
Company will revise its revenue recognition policy disclosure to enhance the description of its
accounting policy for rebates and returns (please refer to our response in Comment b).
COMMENT:
b) Expand your disclosure of the factors that you consider in estimating your sales returns
accrual. Specifically, please address how you consider factors such as levels of FARESTON
inventory in your distribution channels and FARESTONs estimated remaining product shelf life,
particularly since you disclose that you accept product returns near their expiration date.
RESPONSE:
b) In addition to assessing actual and historical product returns in estimating its accrual for
product returns, the Company considers the amount of product in the distribution channel and the
remaining months of product dating. The Companys current return policy states that customers may
return product with up to 180 days of effective dating remaining and for a period of up to 90 days
after the expiration of the product. The Company obtains certain data from various sources
including from its three largest wholesale distributors who accounted for 94% of its FARESTON
product sales in 2005, which includes FARESTON inventory levels
Page Five
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
and FARESTON sales by the distributors, and end-customer demand data (IMS consumption data).
The Company utilizes this data to estimate the remaining number of months of FARESTON product
in the distribution channel and the remaining number of months of effective dating of the FARESTON
product in the distribution channel. In the event that a certain amount of FARESTON product in a
distributors inventory exceeds the amount that is forecasted to be sold prior to the product
expiring, the Company considers the potential product return in estimating its product return
accrual.
In future filings beginning with its Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2006, the
Company will expand its financial statement footnote and critical accounting policy
disclosures in a manner substantially consistent with the following:
Critical Accounting Policies
Revenue Recognition
We recognize net product sales revenue from the sale of FARESTON less deductions for
estimated sales discounts and sales returns. We recognize revenue from product sales when the
goods are shipped and title and risk of loss pass to the customer and the other criteria of
SAB 104 and FAS 48 are satisfied. We account for rebates to certain governmental agencies as
a reduction of revenue. We accept returns of products within 180 days of its expiration date and for a period of up to 90 days after the expiration date. We
estimate our accrual for product returns based on factors which include historical product
returns and estimated product in the distribution channel which is estimated to exceed its
expiration date. At March 31, 2006 and December 31, 2005, the Companys accrual for product
returns was $368,000 and $274,000, respectively. If actual future results are different than
our estimates, we may need to adjust our estimated accrual for product returns, which could
have an effect on earnings in the period of the adjustment.
COMMENT:
c) To the extent that the information you consider in b. is quantifiable, disclose both
quantitative and qualitative factors and discuss the extent of availability and your use of
information from external sources; for example, end-customer demand data compared to inventory
levels. In discussing your estimate of product returns, consider disclosing the total amount of
FARESTON in sales dollars that you believe could potentially be returned as of the most recent
balance sheet date, disaggregated by expiration period, if any.
Page Six
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
RESPONSE:
c) Please see also response to Comment b above. The Company estimates the number of months
of inventory in the distribution channel for its three largest wholesale distributors based on
inventory levels and sales data provided by the distributors. Based on the number of months of
inventory on hand, the Company estimates whether the product on hand at the distributor has a
sufficient number of remaining months of effective dating in order to be consumed prior to the
expiration date of the product. The FARESTON product has 36 months of effective dating from the
time of manufacturing. The manufacturing, packaging and shipping process on average consumes six months of effective dating. Therefore, the
FARESTON product has on average 30 months of effective dating at the time it arrives at the GTx
warehouse. The Company estimates the number of months of remaining effective dating based upon
the month the product is shipped to the distributor. At the time the
Company acquired the rights to FARESTON on January 1, 2005, it also acquired and repackaged the
remaining inventory of FARESTON from Shire. Therefore, the initial product shipped to
distributors by GTx had approximately fifteen months of remaining expiry dating. The Company
took into consideration the remaining effective dating of the FARESTON product acquired from
Shire in estimating its accrual for sales returns.
At March 31, 2006 and December 31, 2005, the Companys accrual for product return was
$368,000 and $274,000, respectively.
COMMENT:
d) If applicable, discuss any shipments made as a result of incentives and/or in excess of your
wholesalers inventory levels in the ordinary course of business, in particular as they pertain to
your rebate accruals, which are inherently affected by the underlying product sales volumes and
growth. Please also discuss your revenue recognition policy for such shipments.
RESPONSE:
d) Shipments of FARESTON by GTx have not historically been influenced by incentives and/or been
in excess of our wholesale distributors inventory levels in the ordinary course of business.
The Company has not provided any specific sales incentives to its wholesale distributors. It is
the Companys policy to review increases in sales volume in connection with product price
increases to determine if customers are purchasing more inventory than they can reasonably sell
in the ordinary course of business prior to the expiration of the product, based on historical
data. An estimated sales return allowance and reduction of revenue would be recorded for any
sales, which the Company estimates, may be returned due to overstocking. The Companys revenue
recognition policy requires that accruals for rebates, discounts, and product returns be
recorded as a reduction of product revenues.
Page Seven
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
COMMENT:
e) For the year ended December 31, 2005 and separately for the quarter ended March 31, 2006,
provide a roll-forward of each accrual that includes the following:
|
|
|
beginning balance; |
|
|
|
|
current estimate related to sales made in current period; |
|
|
|
|
current estimate related to sales made in prior periods (this item will not be
applicable for the year ended December 31, 2005); |
|
|
|
|
actual returns or credits in current period related to sales made in current period; |
|
|
|
|
actual returns or credits in current period related to sales made in prior periods (this
item will not be applicable for the year ended December 31, 2005); and |
|
|
|
|
ending balance |
RESPONSE:
e) The Company did not expect significant FARESTON product returns during 2005 and the first
quarter of 2006 as a result of the expiration dates of the product sold during those periods.
The actual product returns received were in line with the Companys expectations. The Company
does expect FARESTON product returns in future periods as any unsold product in the distribution
channel approaches its expiration date. The Companys only significant contra revenue account
is product returns. The following tables provide a roll-forward of the product returns accrual
for the specified periods.
|
|
|
|
|
For the year ended December 31, 2005: |
|
|
|
|
Beginning balance |
|
$ |
0 |
|
Current estimate related to sales made in current period |
|
|
276,258 |
|
Current estimate related to sales made in prior periods |
|
|
0 |
|
Actual returns or credits in current period related to sales
made in current period |
|
|
2,457 |
|
Actual returns or credits in current period related to sales
made in prior period |
|
|
0 |
|
|
|
|
|
Ending balance |
|
$ |
273,801 |
|
|
|
|
|
Page Eight
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
July 21, 2006
|
|
|
|
|
For the quarter ended March 31, 2006: |
|
|
|
|
Beginning balance |
|
$ |
273,801 |
|
Current estimate related to sales made in current period |
|
|
98,155 |
|
Current estimate related to sales made in prior periods |
|
|
0 |
|
Actual returns or credits in current period related to sales
made in current period |
|
|
0 |
|
Actual returns or credits in current period related to sales
made in prior period |
|
|
4,076 |
|
|
|
|
|
Ending balance |
|
$ |
367,880 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In connection with responses to your comments, the Company acknowledges that: |
|
|
|
|
the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the
filing; |
|
|
|
|
staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose
the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and |
|
|
|
|
the Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by
the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the
United States. |
We hope the responses provided above will be sufficient to address the comments outlined in
your letter of June 27, 2006. Please let us know if you require any additional information.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Best regards,
|
|
|
/s/ Mark E. Mosteller
|
|
|
Mark E. Mosteller |
|
|
Vice President and Chief Financial Officer |
|
|